After Gene breaks his favorite, extremely rare '70s era Christmas record, Tina and Louise join him in the search for another copy. Meanwhile, Teddy wants to do a neighborhood Secret Santa with Bob and Linda.
Quest roles:
Andy Kindler(Mort (voice)), John Michael Higgins(Doug (voice)), David Wain(Courtney (voice)), Tim Meadows(Mike (voice)), Ron Funches(Patrick (voice)), Kulap Vilaysack(Farrah (voice)), Dana Snyder(Percy McTinsel-Bud (voice))