When the victim's younger sister comes looking for her, the team re-opens the 2006 case of a missing Amish girl who was murdered while she was in Philadelphia experiencing the Amish rite of passage called "rumspringa".
Quest roles:
Mackenzie Mauzy(Anna Gunden), Shailene Woodley(Sarah Gunden), Robyn Lively(Miriam Gunden), Ashlee Gillespie(Rachel Wagler), Christopher Shand(Jakob Beachy), Sean Wing(Vince Patrielli), Patricia Bethune(Penny Davoran), Jesse C. Boyd(Rowdy Amish Teen #2), James Ingersoll(Phil Corado), Chip Joslin(Mose Wagler)