As Mike goes to great lengths to keep Leigh from uncovering his plans to throw her a surprise birthday party, Eve develops a crush on a substitute teacher at school, unaware that he has feelings for Annie.
Quest roles:
Samantha Bee(Dr. Young), Jake Lacy(Scott), Kevin Carolan(Carnival Guesser), Kimiye Corwin(Pedicurist), Evan O'Reilly(Singer), Tim Intravia(Silver Man), Rajeev Pahuja(Carnival Worker (uncredited))