After discovering the pirate's plan to harvest their organs, the survivors attempt to escape the island. Karen must make a difficult decision that echoes a moment from her past. Will the pirates remain the captains now?
Quest roles:
George Basil(Chet), Will McLaughlin(Bruce), Lela Elam(Diane from Toledo), Ravi Patel(Tank Top), Ebonee Noel(The Barracuda), Patrick Cox(Flannel), Marc Evan Jackson(Father Daddy), Sara Paxton(Sister Grace), Katie Henoch(Sister Harmony)