Lilly re-investigates the case of a murdered church organist (John Walcutt), when his Alzheimer's-stricken widow (Isabella Hofmann) begins having flashbacks of the night in question. Lilly's investigation has both Mitchell's son, Ryan (Jimmi Simpson), and daughter, Tina (Daisy McCrackin), demanding Lilly close the search.
Quest roles:
Kevin McCorkle, Douglas Smith, Jimmi Simpson, Aimee Teegarden(Tina Bayes (1990)), Isabella Hofmann, Kerrie Keane, Kelli Dawn Hancock(Ashley), Tisha Frazier(Dani), Liz Davies(Delores), Todd Berry(Tom Walsh), John Walcutt(Mitchell Bayes), Justin Chambers(Chris Lassing), Daisy McCrackin(Tina Bayes (2003))