In this variation of "The Tell-Tale Heart", Phoebe plagiarizes from a poetry book and uses one of the poems as her entry in a poetry contest. She wins, with her prize being a trophy resembling poet Emily Dickinson. Then, the trophy haunts Phoebe into confessing.
Quest roles:
Carol Kane(Emily Dickinson Trophy (voice)), George Takei(Phoebe's Father (voice)), Jean Smart(Phoebe's Mother (voice)), Christopher Walberg(Stinky Peterson (voice)), David Wohl(Principal Wartz (voice)), Dan Butler(Mr. Simmons (voice))